Battle of Monte Cassino
Following Operation HUSKY in Sicily, the Allies invaded southern Italy with landings in September 1943. Naples and Foggia fell on 1 October 1943, bringing significant new airfields into Allied hands. airfields that were immediately restored and expanded. Allied air operations that previously had to be based in Sicily, near the limit for fighters, could now operate from the new bases in Italy to provide fighter cover or bombers to support the Allied drive north toward Rome.
Cassino, Italy in foreground with Castle Cassino on small hill and the Monte Cassino Monastery on the large hill behind. Photo taken 6 February 1944.
Background of the Battle of Monte Cassino
Following initial British and Canadian beachheads in Calabria and the American invasion of the Salerno/Naples area, the Allied drive north toward Rome proved hard to do. Both the west coast route and the Route 6 central mountain route were blocked by the Germans. In late 1943, after a fierce battle at San Pietro, a stalemate developed south of the German Winter Line, a set of three defensive perimeters of interlocking bunkers and fortifications that sealed off southern Italy. In addition to German defenses, severe weather during December 1943 - January 1944 created tens of thousands of casualties in the harsh Italian mountain terrain.
The Gustav Line, the northernmost and most formidable of three German Winter Line defensive belts, was anchored by Monte Cassino and the Garigliano and Rapido Rivers. The town of Cassino, about 85 miles southeast of Rome, was a mile east of Monte Cassino, the 1700 foot hill top that guarded the entrance to the Liri valley, the most expeditious route to Rome on Route 6. The Abbey of Monte Cassino, on the site of ancient Roman fortifications, was the place where St. Benedict of Norcia established the first monastery of his Benedictine Order, in 529 A.D.
Although the Germans did not actually occupy the monastery building, they built heavily fortified emplacements and observation posts next to the monastery walls, taking full advantage of the terrain and Allied reluctance to attack the Abbey. Allied planners had to treat the entire hilltop as a key military target, dominating the Cassino valley, and the obstacle to their objective of cracking the Gustav Line. On Allied maps Monte Cassino was Hill 516, controlled by the enemy and the source of fire against Allied forces.
First Battle of Cassino
At the same time as the Allies attempted to outflank the Winter Line by landing at Anzio, the first attack was launched to break the Gustav Line. The Allies launched their offensive on 12 January 1944, with the French Expeditionary Corps assaulting Cassino and the British 10 Corps attempting to exploit previous gains on the Garigliano River. Neither attack succeeded in breaking through the Gustav Line, although limited progress was made. One week later, on 20 January, the U.S. II Corps attacked in the center of the Fifth Army front, attempting to cross the Rapido River. After two days of bitter fighting and heavy losses, the II Corps' 36th Infantry Division was forced to break off its attack. The assault on the Gustav Line, the lynch-pin of the Allied plan of which Anzio was a part, had bogged down. The expected rapid breakthrough became a bloody war of attrition. The U.S. 34th Division lost 2,200 men attempting to penetrate German prepared defenses on the Rapido River, failing in attempts to cross the river valley under German fire directed from Monte Cassino. The other Allied forces did a little better, crossing to the north of the Rapido, but were ultimately forced to withdraw.
Second Battle of Cassino
After considerable debate and delay due to fear of offending Christians worldwide, the Allies decided the monastery had to be bombed to dislodge the Germans. After trying leaflets urging the Germans to abandon the site, on 15 February 1944 American bombers dropped 1,150 tons of high explosives and incendiary bombs on the Abbey, reducing the entire top of Monte Cassino to smoking rubble. A simultaneous ground assault went on for three days, attempting to reach the high ground of the monastery. The Germans held on to the mountain top, although the Commonwealth troops from New Zealand and India were successful in capturing some ground in and around Cassino. However, with the Germans continuing to hold the high ground of Monte Cassino, there was little chance of expanding the gains. The Germans actually had suffered very heavy casualties, but this was unknown to the Allies at the time.
Third Battle of Cassino
For another month, inconclusive ground fighting in wet weather continued around Hill 516, leading to another bomb run, this time with 500 planes dropping 1,400 tons of bombs on Cassino and the mountain on 15 March 1944. The town of Cassino was flattened by the bombing and artillery bombardment. Despite the heavy damage, again the German defenders clung to the ruins, actually improving their defenses in the rubble left by the bombings. About 75% of the town was in Allied hands by this time, but Allied troops could not fully overcome the stubborn resistance that went on building by building in town and yard by yard in the surrounding rugged terrain. German positions remained intact and were vigorously defended. Mechanized war with tanks was impossible in the rugged terrain and amid the bombing debris, forcing hand to hand combat by soldiers supplied by mules.
Fourth Battle of Cassino
Monte Cassino area, April 1944.
Cassino was finally taken in Operation DIADEM, the Allied spring 1944 offensive in Italy, beginning on 11 May under the overall command of General Sir Harold Alexander. Using a well coordinated combined force of infantry backed up by bombing and artillery, the Gustav Line was finally breached on 14 May. US Fifth Army to the south and west and the British Eighth Army in the center combined in a dual strike while VI US Corps at Anzio finally broke out along the coast and to the rear of the Gustav Line. Eighth Army succeeded in cutting Highway 6, the main road linking the south of Italy to Rome.
On Monte Cassino itself, two divisions of the II Polish Corps battled the German 1st Parachute Division for the mountain. After days of attacks and counterattacks in hand to hand fighting, on the night of 17 May the German garrison abandoned Monte Cassino as part of a general German retreat from the Gustav Line to new defensive lines to the north. At 10:30 in the morning, 18 May 1944, the Polish flag was raised over the Monte Cassino rubble, ending the battle.
Allied troops continued the drive north, capturing Rome on 4 June 1944, although most German forces escaped the Allied advance and survived to form new defensive positions north of Rome. Immediately after the liberation of Rome, Operation OVERLORD in Normandy made the Italian Campaign a side show to the cross-channel invasion and its aftermath.
Controversy Over the Bombing of Abbey Monte Cassino
The decision to bomb the Monastery of Monte Cassino is still controversial. It is argued that there was no need to destroy the treasured Abbey and by doing so the Allies gave a propaganda victory to Hitler. After the capture, it became clear that the Germans had not occupied the monastery buildings themselves, although they were quite nearby. However, at the time, to the troops struggling up the slopes toward the massive walls of the monastery, it was clearly a shelter for the German defenders and had to be destroyed for the defenses to be dislodged.
U.S. Fifth Army commander Lt. Gen. Mark Clark wrote in this memoirs that bombing Monte Cassino was a mistake, but other military leaders did not shrink from accepting responsibility for what was necessary at the time against a stubborn enemy.
The Monastery itself was reconstructed after World War II and was reconsecrated by Pope Paul VI in 1964.
Recommended Books about the Battle of Monte Cassino
Find More Information on the Internet
There are many fine websites that have additional information on this
topic, too many to list here and too many to keep up with as they come and go.
Use this Google web search form to get an up to date report of what's out there.
For good results, try entering this: 1944 monte cassino. Then click the Search button.